If you're inquiring on really natural shades from Ecco Bella, may I suggest either the Café Au Lait, or Napa Grape, or even the Rosewood, which is the darkest of the 3 I mention ,but worn lightly looks very natural. You can also check out the Vitamin E Lip Smoothers, and the Rhubarb is a soft berry color and is more glossy but stays on really well. If you like Lip Glosses in a tube, check out the Good For You Ecco Bella Lip Gloss color called Peace. It's a very natural soft sand color and is fun to apply abit on top of any lipstick shade for that extra highlighting 'effect'.
HI, I got this ingredient list from Vitacost's website. Depending on the color of lipstick you buy some of them may have carmine.Ingredients: Castor oil, isopropyl palmitate (from palm oil), candelilla wax, 100 IU vitamin E, organic calendula oil, organic chamomile oil, organic jojoba oil, flower wax coated iron oxides. May contain carmine.
No dye lanolins are used at all.
The Almond is considered a nude, it is a soft brown with gold undertones and is vegan, no carmine.